Forgive me for sitting on the sidelines for a week and watching the news from the bleachers. What I’m going to talk about is not the event, but the aftershocks.
Last week, the American Medical Association officially classified Obesity as a “disease state with multiple pathophysiological aspects requiring a range of interventions”, a hotly debated change that follows in the footsteps of the American Association of Clinical Endocrinologists (2012) and The Obesity Society (2008), and highly supported by the American College of Cardiology and the American Heart Association. It wasn’t a shoo-in: the AMA Committee appointed to the task recommended AGAINST the disease classification, but the AMA House of Delegates – the providers – overruled that recommendation and passed the motion with a large (no pun intended) majority (276-181: 60.4% to 39.6%).
The professionals arguing against the classification fell back on the same old sorry party line – there are no specific conditions associated with obesity, and that it is a risk factor for other diseases but nothing more.
The AMA made a kind and accurate comparison to other lifestyle-related diseases: “The suggestion that obesity is not a disease but rather a consequence of a chosen lifestyle exemplified by overeating and/or inactivity is equivalent to suggesting that lung cancer is not a disease because it was brought about by individual choice to smoke cigarettes.” Or diet and hypertension, or alcohol and cirrhosis, or sex and HIV, or drugs and Hepatitis C, or motorcycle accidents and brain injury among others. We are imperfect beings and we seek physical experience, sometimes to excess and to our detriment.
When they declared obesity a disease, you may have heard me doing my happy dance in my office where I practice Functional Medicine and Integrative Psychiatry, and treat obesity daily. Finally, I thought, recognition that obesity is NOT simple thermodynamics of calories in = calories burned. If it was that simple, everyone who ever lost weight would still be thin.
Not Everyone is Happy with the New Classification
I was stunned at the subsequent backlash that occurred, especially since all of the scientific evidence over the last decade points toward obesity as a progressive metabolic, endocrine, toxic, nutritional, psychiatric and inflammatory disease that sabotages weight loss efforts, no matter what the diet. Why would you NOT want obesity classified as a disease?
On Twitter, hashtag “#IAMNOTADISEASE took over with a vengeance. People worried about the new obesity disease classification as (1) being more stigmatizing than being fat in a supposedly thin society, (2) overmedicalizing obesity because not everyone who is obese is unhealthy, (3) catering to the pharmaceutical and device industry, (4) being inaccurate because there is debate about Body Mass Index as an inaccurate and fallible measure of obesity and (5) promoting racial discrimination based on the epidemiology of obesity.
Let me try and answer their concerns:
Re: Stigmatization: People were offended and suspicious, especially the community of fat advocates. Apparently the word “disease” is worse than the word “fat”. I’m not sure how an already stigmatized condition can be further stigmatized, but I understand how an oppressed group may be overly sensitive to any slight or comment that seems derogatory.
Re: Overmedicalizing: Sigh. I understand that part of fat advocacy has been the Health At Every Size (HAES) campaign, which includes healthy eating and movement and a healthy balanced lifestyle, all of which I support and work with my patients daily to achieve. At any size. However the scientific physiological data just doesn’t support long-term “healthy obesity” on a micro or macroscopic level. Fat cells are metabolically active, and too many of them are eventually harmful. Years of morbid obesity will eventually erode joints, and take its toll on organ systems. Maybe the advocates need to change the term to “healthy obesity at this moment, but maybe not in 20 or 30 or 40 years”.
Re: Industry Profit: Yes. Assuming the pharmaceutical and device industries, and the supplement industry, and the medical and nutritional and even organic food industries will benefit is a given. They all always find a way. But the argument about the pharmaceutical industry making money off fat people is just simply a cost shift from the multi-billion dollar supplement and fitness industry that victimizes the gullible and the desperate among us.
Re: Disagreement within the medical and scientific community: There will always be disagreement within the medical community on disease and treatment – that is the definition of evolution. In a brilliant Aeon magazine essay The Obesity Era, science writer David Berreby said this, “One possible response, of course, is to decide that no obesity policy is possible, because ‘science is undecided’. But this is a moron’s answer: science is never completely decided; it is always in a state of change and self-questioning, and it offers no final answers.”
Re: Racial Discrimination: Absolutely, I give a nod that poverty is indeed associated with obesity in the United States, and a caution to not overinterpret or universalize epidemiologic data. In other countries, it is the middle and upper classes that are associated with obesity (such as India). I’m hoping that underserved populations will be able to see professionals about their weight, and have it covered, instead of not being able to afford a diet program or a gym. In my real dreams, there are urban community gardens, and decent produce and quality protein and fresh fruit in the food deserts, and safe areas to exercise or walk. The causal paradox of hunger and cheap food and obesity are not being ignored by classifying obesity as a disease. To the contrary, this reclassification calls attention to ALL causes of obesity – physiological, psychological, social, environmental, genetic, hormonal, economic.
What really struck me was that people who were upset about the obesity disease classification said “I AM NOT A DISEASE”, not “I don’t HAVE a disease”. Yet they don’t say I AM ASTHMA. The AMA didn’t say “you are a disease”. Those of you who have read my blogs before know that I am a fervent proponent of turning the word “diabetic” back into an adjective where it belongs, not a noun. You are NOT a diabetic. You HAVE diabetes. You are NOT a disease.
So what is this about?
Maybe, just maybe, calling obesity a disease implies it is hopeless.
So let’s look at the actual AMA proclamation and how it is helpful, not hopeless.
Is Obesity Really a Disease?
The AMA says these are the “common criteria in defining a disease: 1) an impairment of the normal functioning of some aspect of the body; 2) characteristic signs or symptoms; and 3) harm or morbidity”.
Re Impaired physiologic functioning: “there is now an overabundance of clinical evidence to identify obesity as a multi-metabolic and hormonal disease state including impaired functioning of appetite dysregulation, abnormal energy balanced, endocrine dysfunction including elevated leptin levels and insulin resistance, infertility, dysregulated adipokine signaling, abnormal endothelial function and blood pressure elevation, nonalcoholic fatty liver disease, dyslipidemia, and systemic and adipose tissue inflammation”.
Re characteristic signs and symptoms: “including the increase in body fat and symptoms pertaining to the accumulation of body fat, such as joint pain, immobility, sleep apnea, and low self-esteem.”
Re Associated Harm or Morbidity: “The physical increase in fat mass associated with obesity is directly related to comorbidities including type 2 diabetes, cardiovascular disease, some cancers, osteoporosis, polycystic ovary syndrome.”
In my opinion, the AMA made the case for obesity as a disease. It gets even worse scientifically. In a groundbreaking study published in PLOS ONE 6/26/2013, OVERWEIGHT may be a disease also. In a study of 200,000 people affected by a common genetic variant, even a ONE UNIT increase in BMI is associated with a 20 per cent increased risk of developing heart failure. Further, the study also confirms that obesity leads to higher insulin values, higher blood pressure, worse cholesterol values, increased inflammation markers, and increased risk of diabetes.”
How Does Classifying Obesity as a Disease Help Patients and Providers?
How does a disease classification help providers and patients give and receive treatment and help?
1) Insurance Coverage. In my world, a diagnosis of Morbid Obesity is not yet reimbursable. I find myself having to scratch out an explanation of an eating disorder or anxiety or irritable bowel syndrome to cover the time and appointments that are needed for someone to completely change their lifestyle. In addition, prescription medications that are sometimes helpful will be covered, as will surgeries for people who need drastic measures to prevent end-stage disease before they develop those diseases. Patients with obesity will be able to see the dietitian or nutritionist, unlike the present where those appointments are not covered unless you already have diabetes, and then, only once a year. Losing weight requires a great deal of support – people should be able to see their professionals as often as needed. And maybe, in an ideal world, physical therapy will be expanded to include physical fitness.
2) Reducing Weight Bias among Health Care Providers. One fact to consider is that currently many, if not most, physicians and medical students and nurses and other health care providers are biased against obese patients. Interestingly, health care professionals also freely admit they have no skill or training or knowledge in how to treat these patients’ obesity other than treating the associated late-stage diseases. We providers don’t like it when we have no idea what to do for someone. A formal disease classification opens the medical school curriculum floodgates with research, algorithms, evidence, and support.
3) Politics, Policy, and Funding The AMA decision does not have legal clout, but becomes a crucial guideline when setting medical policy and health regulations, and determining funding priorities. Honestly? I dislike the politicians legislating medical care as much as anyone, but at this point, I dislike lip service for obesity more. Fund us, and let us go to work.
How does Obesity as a Disease Benefit the Integrative Practitioner?
Functional Medicine combines the best of medical science with the newest of medical science, what some people consider “holistic”. I am just as likely to order labs, write a prescription for medication as I am to recommend a vitamin or herb, but the bulk of the healing occurs with lifestyle changes – one small change at a time – with lasting huge effects. You can’t stop eating cheeseburgers and ice cream because you have an essential fatty acid deficiency and your brain is screaming for them. But once they are replenished in your body, using the correct ratio of fatty acids and a reputable brand which does not contain mostly junk fish oil, the cravings disappear. Not a thought, not a wish, not a command in your mind. Gone.
The more we learn, the more we have to offer. For some of the data, we’re currently working off of minimal research and findings, with a great deal of mainstream opposition. Remember the position of acupuncture 25 years ago? Now…acupuncture is totally mainstream, and covered by many insurers. We are in the early years with alternative obesity treatment. There is a dearth of substantial credible data, and we are relying mostly on observational or exploratory data or small studies lacking statistical power. And yet we know from those patients, one at a time, who have responded, that many alternative treatments have potential in the treatment of obesity.
Weight loss coach Steve Nicander, who lost 400 pounds through lifestyle changes, and promotes an holistic weight loss program, “Healthful Hope”, expresses this beautifully. Says Steve, “I may have lost a massive amount of weight, but in my mind I will always consider myself to be obese and have that potential to be again. What I think this will do is allow for better treatment methods starting with our chronic childhood obesity problem allowing them to feel more comfortable discussing it with their health care providers. I hope the best and biggest change coming from this new awareness is improved training in medical schools in dealing with this epidemic, where education is at a bare minimum. Holistic approaches and non-invasive measures, as you know, can still reverse the weight and cure the underlying diseases.”
Nothing works for everyone, most treatments work on someone. Everyone needs to clean up their diet and increase their movement, but, as we now know, that may not be enough for people. Lately, I’m lying on my new pulsed electromagnetic stimulation device and running the obesity program to see if I lose weight with the same lifestyle (which is pretty organic but a little underexercised and overworked). So far down 7 pounds, is this for real? At the same time, I’m happy to share the latest animal data on green coffee beans which demonstrates absolutely no prevention of weight gain. I feel like I’m pitching blindfolded. It’s not enough. I need more, you need more, and just like the commercial with those adorable kids… I WANT MORE. The door just creaked open.
This blog was first published on the American Holistic Medical Association blog
I am on an Obesity Mission. I’m going to single handedly (with lots of great help) change the way we treat obesity. And the way we treat obese people. The following is an open letter to all the skinny doctors, trainers, dieticians and therapists in the world …
WITH ALL DUE RESPECT DOCTORS AND COLLEAGUES…YOU ARE WRONG ABOUT THE MEDICAL EVIDENCE!
Listen up. (That’s me BEFORE circa 2003). A fat doctor. Imagine. (Scroll down to see the AFTER).
Obesity is NOT simple thermodynamic imbalance. It’s not how many calories we eat and how little we exercise. That may be true for people who are overweight and have 20 or 30 or 40 pounds to lose. Any diet and exercise program that is basically healthy nutrition and movement will work for them; it’s just a matter of matchmaking – the right program for the right person.
For the rest of us, the obese…Eat Less Move More fails 95% of the time. Worse yet, severe restrictive diet and exercise may worsen, not improve, the obese person’s health. Emotional Eating and Behavioral Control don’t fare any better, but at least they don’t ruin someone’s health!
Here’s me with a recent 2010 AFTER (down 100 lbs). Winning an award because I figured out how to lose weight and how to apply that knowledge to every patient I see and how to teach to anyone who will listen. (Thanks Kaiser!)
Here’s what I know about Obesity. I’ll share it all with you in the hopes that you will go back to your exam rooms and order some labs for starters.
Obesity is a medical condition of serious inflammation, chronic pain, disordered endocrine function, changes in insulin metabolism, altered brain chemistry, food sensitivities, serious vitamin and mineral deficiencies.
Obesity is a psychosocial condition of depression and hopelessness and isolation and loneliness.
Obesity is a spiritual condition of broken hearts and broken souls and broken families. It’s not how we feel inside, but it’s how the outside sees and reacts to us. It hurts to be fat. Physically, psychologically, socially and spiritually.
Now…does that sound like gluttony to you?
Yet, if I go to any one of you, even the most esteemed physician or medical center, you will tell me Eat Less, Move More. Or you’ll send me to your behavioral health department because clearly there’s something wrong with me. There I will receive medication for depression and six weeks of therapy about how I’m a good person and I should love myself and not eat chocolate. Or you’ll throw up your hands and say I can have surgery, but I’m not sick enough to qualify yet. Wait a few years.
You can treat obesity, it’s easy. You already know how. But it’s not Eat Less Move More. And it’s not emotional.
It’s replacing Vitamin D, detecting Vitamin B12, A, Zinc, Iodine deficiencies, finding food allergies even when the lab tests are not sufficiently sensitive, treating pain and weakness with gentle movement therapy, jumping on that sleep disorder, correcting inflammation and insulin resistance, helping that sluggish thyroid, changing obesigenic medications to those with a more neutral weight profile. And yes, sometimes it’s sending us to behavioral health, but not nearly as often as you think.
You can treat obesity by understanding the many pathways and reactions that have been altered in response to excess inflammatory adipose and its causes. And one by one, correcting them. Just like you learned in medical school. Imagine that.
And I’m here to tell you, if you do that, your patients will lose weight. And feel better. And love you forever.
Announcing the opening of Stein Wellness Centers in May 2011, dedicated to comprehensive and integrative treatment of obesity. In person and distance.
Offering free consultation to any medical professional.
See one, do one, teach one.
Sara Stein, M.D.
Stein Wellness Centers (opening May 2011)
http://SteinWellness.com (under construction)